The Best Riley Sager Books Ranked: From "Final Girls" to "The Only One Left"
- Merce Miller
- Sep 5
- 2 min read
When it comes to pulse-pounding suspense and twisty thrillers, Riley Sager has become a must-read author for fans of modern psychological suspense. With atmospheric settings, shocking twists, and haunting plots, his books grip readers from the first page to the last. Below, the five best Riley Sager books ranked; a perfect starting point if you’re new to his work or deciding which one to pick up next.
This site contains affiliate links. I earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
5. "Final Girls"
A chilling psychological thriller about the lone survivor of a brutal massacre, thrust back into the spotlight when another survivor dies and a third resurfaces. As buried memories claw their way back, the fragile life built in the aftermath begins to crumble, leading to a shocking truth that refuses to stay hidden.
You’ll love it if… You enjoy thrillers with a cinematic, edge-of-your-seat feel.
4. "Lock Every Door"
Set in a glamorous but unsettling apartment building, this thriller thrives on claustrophobia, paranoia, and creeping dread. Every locked door hides something, every hallway feels like a trap, and the deeper the mystery runs, the harder it becomes to know who can be trusted.
You’ll love it if… You’re drawn to thrillers with gothic undertones in urban settings.
3. "The Last Time I Lied"
A haunting summer camp mystery that blends nostalgia with chilling revelations. It’s eerie, atmospheric, and layered with secrets that resurface years later—when a woman returns to the camp where her friends vanished, determined to uncover what really happened beneath the surface of those long-ago summer nights.
You’ll love it if… You’re fascinated by the dark side of friendships and promises.
2. "Home Before Dark"
A chilling haunted-house mystery told in dual timelines. An adult woman inherits the sprawling Victorian estate where her family once fled under terrifying circumstances—circumstances immortalized in her father’s bestselling memoir. Skeptical and eager to uncover the truth, she returns to renovate and sell the home, only to encounter eerie echoes from the past. As strange occurrences begin to mirror her father’s account, she must decide whether the book was fiction—or a terrifying reality.
You’ll love it if… You can’t resist a chilling haunted-house story.
"The Only One Left"
Set against the backdrop of a crumbling cliffside mansion with a sinister history. A young caregiver takes on the task of helping an elderly woman who has lived in near-isolation for decades, ever since being accused of a shocking crime that wiped out her family. As she begins to record the woman’s account, questions arise about what really happened in the house and whether the past is as buried as it seems. This is the kind of story that will keep you wide awake long past midnight.
You’ll love it if… You’re hooked by unreliable narrators and jaw-dropping twists.
These five books showcase the very best of Riley Sager’s storytelling—haunting, addictive, and impossible to put down. While his latest release, With a Vengeance (2025), didn’t quite make this list, we are all hopeful that his next novel will be another heavy-hitter to stand alongside his most unforgettable thrillers. Happy reading!
